Smart Solutions For Federal Tax Issues
David Coffin office building

When do simple tax errors raise to criminal tax investigations?

On Behalf of | Apr 11, 2024 | Tax |

The only inevitables in life are death and taxes, but tax filing can be intricate. Unfortunately, this means that errors are common. Though, unlike simple paperwork errors made in every other facet of life, tax errors can have severe consequences. Distinguishing between innocent mistakes and those triggering criminal tax investigations is paramount for taxpayers aiming to stay compliant.

Identifying the catalyst for criminal scrutiny

The Internal Revenue Service primarily conducts audits to verify taxpayers’ accuracy. While most discrepancies are resolved civilly, specific indicators can prompt a criminal probe. This typically occurs when there is evidence of intentional deception, such as underreporting income, inflating deductions or concealing offshore assets.

Intent: the critical element

For an error to escalate to criminal status, there must be a deliberate attempt to mislead the IRS. Simple errors, like mathematical miscalculations or missing forms, usually do not meet this criterion. Nonetheless, if a taxpayer knowingly withholds income or fabricates deductions, it could constitute tax fraud or evasion.

Ramifications of criminal tax offenses

The repercussions for criminal tax violations are severe. Convicted individuals may encounter substantial fines and incarceration. For instance, tax evasion, categorized as a felony, can result in fines of up to $100,000 for individuals ($500,000 for corporations) and/or imprisonment for up to 5 years.

Proactive measures

To sidestep the dire consequences of criminal tax inquiries, taxpayers should implement several precautionary measures. First, maintain meticulous and comprehensive records. Familiarize yourself with tax obligations or consult with professionals. Rectify past returns upon discovering errors, and cooperate transparently with the IRS during audits.


Taxpayers must approach their tax obligations with diligence and integrity. While the IRS acknowledges that errors can arise, deliberate attempts to evade taxes will be met with serious consequences. By staying informed and vigilant, taxpayers can avert the transition from a simple oversight to a criminal investigation.